Install

Get the latest updates as we post them — right on your browser

. Last Updated: 07/27/2016

Executions of Retarded Reviewed

WASHINGTON -- When the U.S. Supreme Court last considered executions of the mentally retarded, only two U.S. states banned the practice. Now, 18 states prohibit it, and that math will weigh on the court as it reconsiders the issue and the fate of a condemned man with an intelligence quotient of 59.

The court debated Wednesday how much public standards have changed since 1989, when the court upheld those executions on a 5-4 vote. Justice Sandra Day O'Connor wrote then that there was "insufficient evidence of a national consensus" against the executions to determine that they were unconstitutionally cruel and unusual punishment.

That question has been settled, the lawyer for convicted Virginia killer Daryl Renard Atkins told the court.

"What is your definition of consensus?" asked Chief Justice William Rehnquist, a question repeated later by other court members. "How many states out of the 50 do you need for a consensus?"

Attorney James Ellis didn't provide a number, but he said there are clear moral concerns about putting to death mentally retarded killers. They should be punished, just not by death, he said.

Twelve states do not execute any murderers and 18 others don't use their death penalties for the retarded.

"That's a super majority," said Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg.

U.S. President George W. Bush has said he opposes executing the mentally retarded. Texas does not have a ban, and the state executed two retarded defendants while he was governor, according to the Death Penalty Information Center. Prosecutors have disputed the IQs of some executed Texas inmates.

Pamela Rumpz, a Virginia assistant attorney general, told justices that public opinion would change overnight if Osama bin Laden was captured, brought to America for trial and argued that he was mentally retarded. She also said that the death penalty is appropriate for people like Atkins, convicted of killing an airman in Virginia.

Atkins, who was 18 at the time, had more than 20 previous felonies and was aware of his wrongdoing, she said.

Atkins has an IQ of 59, considered mildly mentally retarded. People who test 70 or below generally are considered mentally retarded.

There are more than 3,700 people on death row. None of the attorneys could say Wednesday how many of those might be retarded.