Install

Get the latest updates as we post them — right on your browser

. Last Updated: 07/27/2016

Talks Fruitless as NHL Opener Nears

Talks between the NHL Players Association and the league have yielded agreement on where to order out for lunch, but little else.


After nearly seven hours of talks Tuesday, representatives of the two sides scheduled another meeting for Wednesday. But no areas of potential compromise have emerged from the 12 hours of discussion in the last two meetings. If anything, the gap has widened, as each side adheres to its approach to stabilizing costs and helping small-market clubs survive.


"Some serious philosophical differences have to be resolved if we're going to have a deal," said Bob Goodenow, executive director of the National Hockey League players association.


Barring sudden and major concessions from either side, it is unlikely a new agreement will be in place by Oct. 1, when the season is scheduled to open.


The players, who went all of last season without a contract, have said they are willing to do so again if necessary. NHL Commissioner Gary Bettman has already received authorization from owners to invoke a lockout, although he has repeatedly refused to say how seriously he is considering that option.


The league Tuesday rejected a proposal by the players in which a 5 percent levy would be imposed on clubs' revenues and the proceeds disbursed to clubs in small markets. Owners remain fixed on salary controls, as embodied in their plan to set a payroll limit and penalize clubs that exceed that figure. The money would go to small-market teams.


"They're hell-bent for leather on having a salary cap," a source among the players said.


Sources said owners scoffed at the union's claim that its levy on revenues would raise $35 million. Their estimate was $20 million, which they deemed insufficient to help clubs such as Winnipeg and Quebec.


The owners' last proposal, rejected last week by players, would also abolish arbitration -- which the players want to retain -- and relax restrictions on free agency. However, according to that plan, clubs would retain the right to match offers made to free agents. Players want unfettered free agency.


The average player salary has risen from $201,000 in the 1988-89 season to $520,000 last season.


Led by the hard-bargaining Bettman, owners clearly maintain the upper hand. By unilaterally imposing 19 conditions -- including the reduction of game rosters from 18 skaters to 17, forcing players to pay their own way to training camp and obligating those who earn more than $350,000 to pay their own medical insurance -- Bettman cleverly gave himself a handful of bargaining chips to play later, when he needs to pressure players into making significant concessions.


He can now, in the customary give-and-take of negotiations, relent on some of those points and appear to be giving something up while actually coming out even. For example, he will probably agree to restore rosters to 18 skaters. Players have no intention of striking. It would do them no good economically or in a public relations sense. If Bettman locks them out, he and the owners would be cast as the bad guys, and that is how the players want it.