Belarus Shows Signs of Continuing Failed Economic Policies
- Apr. 11 2013 00:00
- Last edited 16:02
MINSK — Shortly after emerging from a crisis that wiped out its foreign currency reserves and forced a 65 percent ruble devaluation,áBelarus appears to be sticking with some of the policies that caused it — but with more caution.
PresidentáAlexander Lukashenko's governmentáis again doling out subsidized loans, raising wages and drafting ambitious economic development plans while shunning International Monetary Fund calls for deep market reforms.
However, analysts say the authorities are acting more carefully this time, and the economy will most likely muddle through this year thanks to continued support fromáRussiaáand possible asset sales or Eurobond issuance.
"Growth will not be stimulated carelessly, the way it was in 2010," saidáDmitry Kruk, aáMinsk-based analyst at theáBelarussian Economic Research and Outreach Center, or BEROC.
The former Soviet republic's government and central bank are planning to reduce inflation to 12 percent this year from 21.7 percent in 2012 while pushing economic growth to 8.5 percent from 1.5 percent.
Some economists say the growth target is unrealistic and will not be met.
"Officials are already preparing excuses for failing to meet this target," saidáYaroslav Romanchukáof theáMinsk-based think tankáMises Center.
Belarussian exports — dominated by oil products, chemicals such as fertilizers, and heavy machinery such as dump trucks and tractors — actually fell 13 percent year-on-year in January, leading to a 71 percent drop in the trade surplus.
The decline was largely a result ofáMinskáending the practice of reselling Russian gasoline and other oil products as solvents and thinners under pressure from Moscow, which says it has been cheated out of up to $2 billion.
But the IMF believesáBelarusáhas also lost much of the competitiveness gains from the 2011 devaluation after the nominal average monthly wage in the state-dominated economy rose by 65 percent during 2012.
This year, the government came up with the idea of boosting productivity through buying new equipment to upgrade existing industrial facilities. Lukashenko has askedáRussiaáfor a $2 billion loan to finance the plan.
But, even with new equipment, managers of state-run companies will have few incentives to become more efficient, says BEROC's Kruk, as long as they have guaranteed sales, access to subsidized loans and no competitors.
"The key to boosting growth rates is creating a competitive environment," Kruk said.
But such reforms, which could also pave the way for a deal with the IMF, are certain to upset the blue-collar work force in factories and industry that forms the core of Lukashenko's support base. They will also face resistance from hardliners in Lukashenko's entourage.
A fresh Russian loan coming on top of $900 million in scheduled tranches from aáMoscow-led bailout fund would, however, helpáBelarusábridge the external financing gap which is set to widen due to weak exports and foreign debt repayments.
The government is also still discussing a new Eurobond issue of at least $500 million. Finally, it can raise some cash by selling assets such as oil refineries, most likely to Russian companies.
Still, according to Russian brokerage VTB Capital,áBelarus' current account deficit is set to more than double this year to $5 billion to $6 billion, which will put some pressure on central bank reserves and the exchange rate.
"We ... expect the ruble to weaken against the dollar this year, easing to as low as 9,600 by the year-end (averaging 8,850)," it said in a note last week
The chances ofáMinskágetting an IMF loan are slim as the fund, disappointed byáBelarus' poor performance since the implementation of the previous program in 2009-2010, wantsáLukashenko's governmentáto commit to unpopular market reforms.
Lukashenko, in power since 1994 and dubbed "Europe's last dictator" by the former U.S. administration, is also at odds with the West over his treatment of political opposition.
TheáEuropean Unionálast year introduced travel bans and asset freezes against him and other local officials and businessmen in response to a crackdown in which several politicians who had run against Lukashenko in the 2010 election were jailed.